Ripple Execs Facing Multi-Million Fines From SEC?

Sasha Hodder, founder of Hodder Law Firm, has started a discussion among lawyers on Twitter about whether Ripple chiefs Brad Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen face fines in their legal battle with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, and if so, what those fines might be.

Hodder wrote in a tweet that if Ripple loses, Larsen will owe the SEC $450 million and Garlinghouse $150 million in fines.

Ripple Execs Could Win While The Company Loses

The original SEC complaint from December 2020 names Larsen, the company’s co-founder, chairman and former CEO, and Bradley Garlinghouse, the company’s current CEO. Both are accused of also making personal, unregistered sales of XRP totaling about $600 million.

Jeremy Hogan, an XRP-loyal community attorney, commented that the SEC has an entirely tougher legal standard to prove against Larsen and Garlinghouse than it does against the company.

“Ripple could lose 100% and the individual defendants could still very well win,” Hogan commented.

Attorney John E Deaton, who is actively participating in the SEC-Ripple litigation with his amicus on behalf of 75,000 investors, added that Judge Torres would have to conclude that both chief executives were reckless in not knowing that XRP is a security.

“Not negligent – but reckless!”, he added.

Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse
Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse. Source: Protocol

The Burden Of Proof For The SEC Is Quite Heavy

Deaton detailed in a lengthy thread why the judge can never conclude that the two executives acted recklessly.

Thus, the attorney lays out that SEC attorneys were allowed to own and trade XRP until March 2019.

In 2014, the Government Accountability Office (USGAO) classified XRP as “a virtual currency used in a decentralized payment system called Ripple.”

A year later, FinCEN and the DOJ settled with Ripple and declared XRP a virtual currency. This forced Ripple to register its XRP sales with FinCEN, not the SEC.

That same year, the CFTC declared that Bitcoin and other similar cryptocurrencies are “properly classified commodities.”

Finally, in 2018, the ominous Hinman speech followed, in which the former director of the Division of Corporation Finance at the SEC classified BTC and ETH as non-securities.

Last but not least, in 2019, the SEC published a framework for digital assets. This states that any crypto asset that can be used for payments and as a substitute for fiat currency “is unlikely to satisfy Howey” requirements.

And those are far from all the arguments Deaton finds. In any case, according to Deaton, Garlinghouse and Larsen are precluded from being found to have acted recklessly.

Reckless means that no reasonable person could believe that XRP was not a security.

A Personal Thing?

Deaton speculates that the SEC’s action against the two executives was a “personal” matter, and in no way did itself any favors:

This was personal and it was a stupid decision by the SEC. […] because it placed a higher burden on the SEC to prove. Let’s be honest, this was hard ball intimidation tactics by the SEC.

At press time, the XRP price was displaying some strength in the 4-hour chart, recording higher lows.

Ripple XRP USDT 2022-12-08
XRP price, 4-hour chart. Source: TradingView

#Ripple #Execs #Facing #MultiMillion #Fines #SEC


Related Posts

Bitcoin Derivatives Market Volumes Show Bullish Trend After 2022 Downturn

Bitcoin continues to see a bullish uptrend across the board, with the derivatives market volume witnessing an upturn in fortunes. BTC prices in futures contracts have begun…

Binance severs ties with Indian crypto exchange WazirX

The debacle between the global cryptocurrency exchange Binance and Zanmai, the operator behind the Indian cryptocurrency exchange WazirX, continues, with a new blog post stating that Binance is…

Why The Shiba Inu Community Is Baffled By Binance 6.4 Trillion SHIB Transfer

Shiba Inu has been making headlines recently as the release of the Shibarium upgrade was teased by Shytoshi Kusama three days ago. However, things might not be…

Sri Lanka against Bitcoin adoption, rejects Draper’s anti-corruption pitch

On a recent visit to Sri Lanka, American billionaire Tim Draper pitched the idea of adopting Bitcoin (BTC) as a legal tender to fight against the corruption…

Layoff Spree Continues: Why This Crypto-Oriented Firm Is Dismissing Some Staff Soon

Last year, many crypto firms and startups went under due to the turmoil in the space. In addition, the devastating impact of the crypto winter affected many…

Value of WisdomTree’s crypto holdings fell 61.9% in Q4

United States fund manager WisdomTree saw the value of its digital asset holdings decline sharply in the fourth quarter, reflecting the prolonged bear market in Bitcoin (BTC)…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *